Indianapolis Colts quarterback Anthony Richardson sparked concern during Thursday’s preseason opener against the Baltimore Ravens after suffering a dislocated pinkie finger. Despite the gruesome appearance, initial X-rays were negative, and ESPN reports he could return to practice as soon as Saturday :cite[1]:cite[4]. This latest injury adds another layer to the ongoing quarterback competition between Richardson and veteran Daniel Jones, who signed a one-year, $14 million deal with the Colts this offseason :cite[1]:cite[2].
Table of Contents
The Injury: A Minor Setback?
Richardson’s injury occurred on just the Colts’ second drive when Ravens linebacker David Ojabo sacked him, forcing the finger to “pop out.” Medical staff quickly reset it, but the team ruled him out as a precaution :cite[1]:cite[2]. Richardson downplayed the issue postgame, stating, “I feel like I was doing decent out there, besides that one play… Still got next game, so I’m not too worried about it” :cite[1]:cite[2].
This scare follows a history of injuries for Richardson, including shoulder, back, and concussion issues since his 2023 debut. His durability remains a question mark, especially compared to Jones’ more extensive (though inconsistent) track record :cite[3]:cite[5].
Richardson vs. Jones: By the Numbers
The Colts’ QB battle hinges on three key traits head coach Shane Steichen prioritizes: accuracy, decision-making, and playmaking ability. Here’s how the two stack up:
| Metric | Anthony Richardson | Daniel Jones |
|---|---|---|
| Completion % | 50.6% | 64.1% |
| Interception % | 3.7% | 2.1% |
| Rush Yards/Attempt | 5.7 | 5.5 |
While Jones leads in accuracy and turnover avoidance, Richardson’s athleticism and big-play potential (6.9 yards/attempt in 2024) keep him in contention :cite[3]:cite[6].
Presason Implications and Future Outlook
Richardson’s quick recovery is critical for his chances to start Week 1. Jones, who completed 10-of-21 passes in relief Thursday, offers a safer but less dynamic option. The Colts’ next preseason game (August 16 vs. Cowboys) could decide the competition :cite[1]:cite[4].
Key factors to watch:
- Durability: Richardson’s injury history vs. Jones’ 70 career starts.
- Scheme Fit: Steichen’s offense thrives with mobile QBs—Richardson’s 6 rushing TDs in 2024 highlight his edge here :cite[6].
- Long-Term Plan: Indianapolis may still eye the 2026 draft if neither QB separates :cite[3].
For more on the Colts’ QB dynamics, see ESPN’s latest analysis or NFL.com’s breakdown.
Conclusion
Richardson’s pinkie injury appears minor, but it underscores the fragility of his promising career. With Jones waiting in the wings, the Colts’ QB decision will shape their 2025 season—and potentially both players’ futures. Stay tuned for updates as preseason unfolds.