The Rise of the Overlooked Film

The phenomenon of the “overlooked film” is nothing new, but it has become more pronounced in the streaming era. With theaters struggling to recover from the pandemic and studios prioritizing franchise films, mid-budget and independent movies often struggle to find an audience. According to Variety, “overlooked can mean many things. Sometimes it means that critics weren’t onboard, even if many viewers disagreed. Or maybe a movie had upwards of 90% on Rotten Tomatoes, like Kristen Stewart’s The Chronology of Water, but got overshadowed during its initial limited release in a brutally tough theatrical market for indie films.”

This year, the issue is compounded by the sheer volume of content. Streaming platforms like Netflix, Hulu, and Amazon Prime release new titles weekly, making it easier than ever for even the most acclaimed films to get lost in the shuffle. As The Film Stage notes, “With an awards season and year-end lists that tend to favor films released in the last few months, many things can go overlooked.” The result? A treasure trove of cinematic gems waiting to be discovered by discerning viewers.

So, what defines an “overlooked” film in 2025? It could be a movie that received glowing reviews but minimal box office attention, a festival darling that never found a distributor, or a genre film that didn’t fit the typical awards-season narrative. Whatever the reason, these films represent the best of what cinema has to offer—if you know where to look.

Why These Films Matter

Overlooked films often push boundaries in ways that mainstream cinema doesn’t. They take risks with storytelling, experiment with form, and tackle subjects that bigger studios might deem too niche or controversial. For example, , a survival thriller based on the true story of a school bus driver and teacher who guided 22 children through the 2018 Camp Fire, was praised for its “white-knuckle immediacy” and “harrowing yet humane” portrayal of heroism. Yet, despite its critical acclaim, it failed to make a splash at the box office or during awards season.

Similarly, The Surfer, starring Nicolas Cage, offers a “rip-roaring examination of how calamity can be just a few choices away,” but its allegorical tone and bleak outlook may have alienated broader audiences. Meanwhile, Bob Trevino Likes It, a heartfelt dramedy about found family, won both the jury and audience awards at SXSW in 2024 but only reached theaters a year later, struggling to find an audience in a crowded marketplace.

These films matter because they reflect the diversity of human experience in ways that blockbusters often don’t. They challenge viewers, provoke thought, and sometimes even redefine genres. As Digital Trends puts it, “From epic blockbusters to independent films, the movie industry provided audiences with exciting content this year. But some of the most exciting content came from the films that flew under the radar.”

The 25 Best Overlooked Films of 2025

Below, we’ve compiled a list of the 25 best overlooked films of 2025, organized by genre and theme. Each entry includes a brief synopsis, key reasons why it stands out, and where you can watch it (if available). Whether you’re a fan of thrillers, dramas, comedies, or experimental cinema, there’s something here for everyone.

Thrillers and Survival Stories

The Lost Bus
Director: TBC
Where to Watch: Theaters (limited release), VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: Based on the true story of a school bus driver and teacher who guided 22 children to safety during the 2018 Camp Fire, The Lost Bus is a masterclass in tension and humanity. Matthew McConaughey and America Ferrera deliver powerhouse performances, and the film’s practical effects immerse viewers in the chaos and courage of the moment. Critics hailed it as one of the most “viscerally urgent” films of the year, yet it barely registered during awards season.
The Surfer
Director: TBC
Where to Watch: Roadside Attractions, Lionsgate
Why It’s Worth Watching: in this allegorical tale set on an Australian beach. The film’s “hazy, sun-drenched nightmare” atmosphere and Cage’s unhinged performance make it a standout, but its dark tone and ambiguous ending may have limited its appeal.
Bring Them Down
Director: Christopher Andrews
Where to Watch: VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: This Irish thriller explores the cycle of violence in a rural community, with Christopher Abbott and Barry Keoghan delivering electrifying performances. The film’s unflinching portrayal of poverty and retribution earned comparisons to classic Irish literature, but it failed to gain traction outside of festival circuits.
Novocaine
Director: TBC
Where to Watch: Paramount+, VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: Jack Quaid stars as a man with a rare disorder that prevents him from feeling pain, leading to a series of absurdly violent and darkly comedic encounters. Digital Trends called it “a gruesome and imaginative action film filled with slapstick humor and poignant drama,” but its niche premise kept it from wider recognition.

Dramas and Character Studies

The Chronology of Water
Director: Kristen Stewart
Where to Watch: Theaters (limited), VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: Stewart’s directorial debut, based on Lidia Yuknavitch’s memoir, is a raw, punk-rock exploration of trauma, addiction, and salvation through swimming. Imogen Poots delivers a revelatory performance, and Stewart’s bold visual style earned comparisons to Terrence Malick. Despite premiering to rave reviews at Cannes, it took three months to secure U.S. distribution.
Bob Trevino Likes It
Director: Tracie Laymon
Where to Watch: Hulu
Why It’s Worth Watching: in this warm-hearted tale of a young woman who finds a new father figure after being cut off by her toxic biological dad. The film’s charm and emotional depth won over festival audiences, but it struggled to find a theatrical foothold.
Lilly
Director: TBC
Where to Watch: Theaters (limited), VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: Patricia Clarkson delivers one of the best performances of her career as Lilly Ledbetter, a real-life whistleblower who fought for equal pay at Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company. Clarkson’s “plainspoken, dogged” portrayal makes the film a powerful tribute to everyday heroism, but it was overshadowed by bigger awards contenders.
My Dead Friend Zoe
Director: Kyle Hausmann-Stokes
Where to Watch: VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: Sonequa Martin-Green stars as a veteran haunted by the death of her friend Zoe (Natalie Morales), who appears as a vivacious ghost. The film’s blend of dark comedy and poignant drama earned praise for its originality, but its unconventional tone may have limited its appeal.

Comedies and Romantic Dramas

Jingle Bell Heist
Director: Michael Fimognari
Where to Watch: Netflix
Why It’s Worth Watching: Olivia Holt and Connor Swindells star as two strangers who team up to rob a department store at Christmastime. What could have been a forgettable holiday rom-com is elevated by sharp writing, unexpected twists, and standout performances from Peter Serafinowicz and Lucy Punch. Critics were surprised by how genuinely good it was, but it got lost in Netflix’s holiday shuffle.
Oh, Hi!
Director: TBC
Where to Watch: Sony Pictures, VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: Molly Gordon and Logan Lerman star in this darkly comedic rom-com about a couple whose relationship takes a bizarre turn after a night of kinky sex. Gordon’s “hilariously unraveled performance” and the film’s willingness to go to uncomfortable places make it a standout, but its niche appeal kept it from breaking out.
Love, Brooklyn
Director: Rachael Abigail Holder
Where to Watch: VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: André Holland stars as a writer navigating love and gentrification in Brooklyn. The film’s “charming, bittersweet” tone and authentic portrayal of modern dating earned comparisons to ‘90s romances like Love Jones, but it failed to find a wide audience.
The Baltimorons
Director: Jay Duplass
Where to Watch: VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: A throwback to the mumblecore genre, this low-budget indie follows a stand-up comedian (Michael Strassner) and a dentist (Liz Larsen) on a chaotic Christmas Eve. Duplass’s signature sincerity and the film’s offbeat humor make it a hidden gem for fans of independent cinema.

Horror and Genre-Benders

Weapons
Director: Zach Cregger
Where to Watch: Warner Bros., VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: From the director of Barbarian, Weapons is a surreal, ensemble horror epic about a town where 17 children mysteriously disappear. Digital Trends called it “one of the most bizarre and terrifying horror movies of the decade,” but its ambition and weirdness may have alienated mainstream audiences.
The Plague
Director: Charlie Polinger
Where to Watch: Theaters (limited), VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: This body horror film, set at a water polo camp, explores male adolescence and bullying through a disturbing allegory. Critics praised its “unsettling atmosphere” and “bold social commentary,” but its grim subject matter limited its appeal.
Sketch
Director: Seth Worley
Where to Watch: VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: A family copes with grief after the loss of their matriarch, whose doodles come to life in this live-action/CG-animated hybrid. The film’s creative visuals and emotional depth earned comparisons to Jumanji and The Babadook, but its unconventional style kept it from wider recognition.
Ghost Trail
Director: Jonathan Millet
Where to Watch: VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: A Syrian refugee searches for answers about his past in this “engrossing surveillance thriller” that blends psychological drama with political urgency. The film’s timely themes and tense storytelling make it a standout, but it struggled to find an audience outside of festivals.

Experimental and International Films

The Ballad of Wallis Island
Director: TBC
Where to Watch: Focus Features, VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: Tim Key, Carey Mulligan, and Tom Basden star in this “funny, moving, and profoundly truthful” film about music, fandom, and mismatched relationships. Its unconventional structure and dark humor make it a standout, but it was overshadowed by more traditional awards fare.
Wild Diamond
Director: Agatha Riedinger
Where to Watch: VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: This French drama explores the toxic allure of social media fame through the story of a 19-year-old glam trainwreck. Critics praised its “pinpoint incisive” portrayal of modern youth culture, but its bleak tone and foreign-language status limited its reach.
Harvest
Director: Athina Rachel Tsangari
Where to Watch: VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: Set in the Late Middle Ages, this allegorical drama examines the twilight of an old social order. Tsangari’s “beautifully rendered” period piece earned acclaim for its political and gender commentary, but it remained under the radar for most audiences.
Pepe
Director: Nelson Carlo De Los Santos Arias
Where to Watch: MUBI
Why It’s Worth Watching: , this “formally radical odyssey” explores ecological and political themes in a way that’s both surreal and deeply affecting. Its ambition and originality make it a must-see for adventurous viewers.

Documentaries and True Stories

American Sweatshop
Director: Uta Briesewitz
Where to Watch: VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: who becomes obsessed with tracking down the creators of a violent video. The film’s “dark, Schrader-esque” tone and timely themes about online trauma make it a standout, but its grim subject matter may have limited its appeal.
Rosemead
Director: Erin Lin
Where to Watch: VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: Lucy Liu stars as a Chinese immigrant who faces an impossible choice when her schizophrenic son’s condition worsens. The film’s “harrowing and all too timely” portrayal of mental health and cultural stigma earned praise, but it struggled to find a wide audience.
The Fishing Place
Director: Rob Tregenza
Where to Watch: VOD
Why It’s Worth Watching: A WWII-era thriller about faith and espionage in rural Norway, this film blends historical drama with existential tension. Tregenza’s “sui generis” career and the film’s “beguiling denouement” make it a hidden gem for fans of slow-burn cinema.

Pro Tips for Discovering Overlooked Films

If you’re eager to explore more overlooked films, here are a few tips to help you uncover hidden gems:

: Many overlooked films premiere at festivals like SXSW, Sundance, and Cannes. Keep an eye on festival lineups and reviews to discover movies before they hit wider release.
: Independent theaters often screen lesser-known films that bigger chains ignore. Support your local indie cinema to catch these movies on the big screen.
: Services like MUBI, Criterion Channel, and even Netflix’s “Hidden Gems” section can be goldmines for overlooked films. Don’t rely solely on algorithms—dig into curated lists and recommendations.
: Critics often champion overlooked films in their year-end lists and weekly reviews. Follow publications like Variety, The Film Stage, and Digital Trends for recommendations.
: Online forums like Reddit’s r/movies or Letterboxd are great places to discover under-the-radar films and read discussions about them.
: Films that receive critical acclaim but are ignored by major awards bodies (like the Oscars or Golden Globes) are often worth seeking out.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do some great films get overlooked?

There are many reasons a film might be overlooked: limited marketing, a crowded release schedule, lack of star power, or simply not fitting into the typical awards-season narrative. Indie films and genre movies are particularly vulnerable to being overshadowed by bigger studio releases.

Where can I watch these films?

Many overlooked films are available on VOD platforms like Amazon Prime, Apple TV, or Vudu. Some may also be streaming on services like Netflix, Hulu, or MUBI. For the most up-to-date availability, check sites like JustWatch or Reelgood.

Are overlooked films usually low-budget?

Not necessarily. While many overlooked films are indie productions, some are mid-budget or even studio films that failed to connect with audiences. The term “overlooked” refers more to the film’s reception than its budget.

How can I support overlooked films?

The best way to support overlooked films is to watch them—especially in theaters, if possible. Share your favorite hidden gems on social media, write reviews, and recommend them to friends. Word of mouth can make a huge difference for these movies.

Do overlooked films ever get a second chance?

Yes! Some overlooked films find new life on streaming platforms, through word of mouth, or by becoming cult classics. For example, The Chronology of Water and The Lost Bus have gained traction thanks to critical reappraisals and festival buzz.

Conclusion

The 25 films on this list represent the best of what 2025’s cinema has to offer—if you’re willing to look beyond the blockbusters and awards darlings. From thrilling survival stories and poignant dramas to experimental genre-benders and dark comedies, these movies prove that some of the most exciting and innovative filmmaking happens outside the mainstream spotlight.

As the film industry continues to evolve, it’s more important than ever to seek out and support overlooked films. These movies challenge us, move us, and remind us why cinema matters. So grab some popcorn, queue up one of these hidden gems, and prepare to discover your new favorite film.

Recommended For You